Lodgepole pine and trembling aspen competition: Neighbourhood studies within 22 to 39 year-old pine plantations of northern British Columbia
Abstract
Six lodgepole pine plantations located within the Sub Boreal Spruce (SBS) biogeoclimatic zone of the northern interior of British Columbia were chosen to study the impacts of neighbourhood aspen competition on the growth of planted lodgepole pine (22–39 years old). At each site, 30 pine trees (CP) were selected as plot centres across the observed range of aspen competition. Information on the six nearest neighbours (NN) and a variety of competition indices were evaluated using linear and nonlinear models. Competition indices based on diameter or height relative to size were found as the best overall predictors of CP growth. Proximity of NN to the CP was found to be inconsistent as a predictor of growth. Individual pine and aspen NN modelling suggested aspen competition had the greatest influence on CP growth restriction. The results do not support aspen thresholds for optimizing the growth of free growing pine plantations. It is recommended that performance-based standards be developed that account for aspen competition intensity and provide guidance for the management of pine stand productivity.
Résumé
On a identifié six plantations de pin tordu situées dans la zone biogéoclimatique de l’épinette sub-boréale (Sub Boreal Spruce-SBS) dans le nord de la Colombie-Britannique intérieure pour y étudier l’impact de la compétition du peuplier environnant sur la croissance de pin tordu dans des plantations de 22 à 39 ans. À chaque endroit, 30 pins (CP) ont été choisis comme centre de placette de manière à représenter tous les niveaux de compétition par le peuplier. Les renseignements pris sur les voisins les plus rapprochés (NN) ont servi à évaluer une variété d’indices de compétition à l’aide de régressions linéaires et non linéaires. On a observé que les indices de compétition basés sur le diamètre ou la hauteur par rapport à la taille donnaient les meilleures prédictions de croissance du CP. La proximité des NN par rapport au CP a donné des prédictions de croissance qui se sont avérées incohérentes. Le modèle individuel pin et peuplier le plus rapproché laisse voir que c’est la compétition exercée par le peuplier qui limite le plus la croissance du CP. Les résultats ne permettent pas d’établir de seuils de compétition du peuplier pour optimiser la croissance des plantations de pins. Nous recommandons d’établir des normes de performance qui tiennent compte de l’intensité de la compétition par le peuplier et qui puisse servir de guides pour gérer la productivité des plantations de pins.
Formats available
You can view the full content in the following formats:
References
BC MFLNRO. 2013. (B.C. Ministry of Forests, Lands and Natural Resource Operations). Silviculture surveys procedures manual. Available from http://www.for.gov.bc.ca/hfp/silviculture/Surveys/SilvicultureSurveyProceduresManual-April_1_2013.pdf
BC MFLNRO. 2015. (B.C. Ministry of Forests, Lands and Natural Resource Operations). Forest and Range Practices Act. Victoria, BC. URL: http://www.bclaws.ca/Recon/document/ID/freeside/00_02069_01
Brooker R.W. and Kikvidze Z. 2008 Importance: An overlooked concept in plant interaction research J. Ecol 96 703 -708
Canham C.D. LePage P.T. and Coates K.D. 2004 A neighbourhood analysis of canopy tree competition: Effects of shading versus crowding Can. J. For. Res 34 778 -787
Chen, S. 1997. Interpreting main effects when a two-way interaction is present. B.C. Min. For., Victoria, B.C. Biometrics Information Pamphlet No. 57, 8 p.
Comeau, P.G., B.S. Biring and G.J. Harper. 1999. Conifer response to brushing treatments: A summary of British Columbia data. B.C. Min. For., Res. Br., Victoria, B.C. Exten. Note 41. Available from https://www.for.gov.bc.ca/hfd/pubs/Docs/En/En41.htm
Cornell J.A. and Berger R.D. 1987 Factors that influence the value of the coefficient of determination in simple linear and nonlinear regression models Phytopathology 77 63 -70
Daniels R. 1976 Simple competition indices and their correlation with annual loblolly pine tree growth For. Sci 22 454 -457
DeLong, C.S. 2007. Relative impact of aspen competition and soil factors on the performance of lodgepole pine and hybrid white spruce in north-central British Columbia. B.C. Min. For. Range, Res. Br., Victoria, B.C. Tech. Rep. 039.
Demaerschalk J.P. and Kozak A. 1974 Suggestions and criteria for more effective regression sampling Can. J. For. Res 4 341 -348
Dhar A., Wang J.R., and Hawkins C.D.B 2015 Interaction of trembling aspen and lodgepole pine in a young sub-boreal mixed-wood stand in central British Columbia Open Journal of Forestry 5 129 -138
Filipescu C.N. and Comeau P.G. 2007 Competitive interactions between aspen and white spruce vary with stand age in boreal mixedwoods For. Ecol. Manage 247 175 -184
Frey B.R., Lieffers V.J., Landhausser S.M., Comeau P.G., and Greenway K.J. 2003 An analysis of sucker regeneration of trembling aspen Can. J. For. Res 33 1169 -1179
Greiss V.C. and Knoke T. 2011 Growth performance, windthrow, and insects: Meta-analyses of parameters influencing performance of mixed-species stands in boreal and northern temperate biomes Can. J. For. Res 41 1141 -1159
Harper G. 2015 Lodgepole pine and trembling aspen mixedwoods: Growth and yield within 22 to 39 year-old pine plantations of northern interior British Columbia Forest. Chron 91 5 502 -518
Harper G.J., O’Neill M., Fielder P., Newsome T., and Delong C. 2009 Lodgepole pine growth as a function of competition and canopy light environment within aspen dominated mixedwoods of central interior British Columbia For. Ecol. Manag 257 1829 -1838
Johnstone W.D. and Pollack J.C. 1990 The influence of espacement on the growth and development of a lodgepole pine plantation Can. J. For. Res 20 10 1631 -1639
Johnstone, W.D. and F.J. van Thienen. 2011. The effects of plantation density on the growth and yield of lodgepole pine: 20 year results. B.C. Min. For. Range. For. Sci. Prog., Victoria, B.C. Exten. Note 102. http://www.for.gov.bc.ca/hfd/pubs/Docs/En/En102.htm
Ledermann T. and Stage A.R. 2001 Effects of competitor spacing in individual-tree indices of competition Can. J. For. Res 31 2143 -2150
Lhotka J.M. and Loewenstein E.F. 2008 An examination of species-specific growing space utilization Can. J. For. Res 38 470 -479
Lieffers V.J., Armstrong G.W., Stadt K.J., and Marenholtz E.H. 2008 Forest regeneration standards: Are they limiting management options for Alberta’s boreal mixedwoods? Forest Chron 84 76 -82
Linkevicius E., Kuliesis A., Rohle H., Schroder J., and Aleinikovas M. 2014 The impact of competition for growing space on diameter, basal area and height growth in pine trees Baltic Forestry 20 2 301 -312
Lorimer C.G. 1983 Tests of age-dependent competition indices for individual trees in natural hardwood stands For. Ecol. Manage 6 343 -360
McKinnon, L.M. and G.J. Kayahara. 2003. Ecology and management of microclimate in boreal mixedwoods. Northeast Science and Information, Ont. Min. Natural Resour., South Porcupine, Ont. Boreal Mixedwood Notes 28. 13 p.
Meidinger, D. and J. Pojar. 1991. Ecosystems of British Columbia. B.C. Min. For., Res. Br., Victoria, B.C. Spec. Rep. Ser. 6. Available from https://www.for.gov.bc.ca/hfd/pubs/docs/srs/Srs06.pdf
Miller J.H., Zutter B.R., Zedaker S.M., Edwards M.B., and Newbold R.A. 2003 Growth and yield relative to competition for loblolly pine plantations to midrotation- A southern United States regional study South J. Appl. For 27 4 237 -252
Miller J.H., Zutter B.R., Zedaker S.M., Edwards M.B., Haywood J.D., and Newbold R.A. 1991 A regional study on the influence of woody and herbaceous competition on early loblolly pine growth South. J. Appl. For 15 169 -179
Mugasha A.G. 1989 Evaluation of simple competition indices for the prediction of volume increment of young jack pine and trembling aspen trees For. Ecol. Manage 26 227 -235
Neter, J., W. Wasserman, and M.H. Kutner. 1990. Applied linear statistical models: Regression, analysis of variance, and experimental designs. 3rd ed. Irwin, Inc.
Newsome, T. 1999. Assessing the effects of aspen competition on lodgepole pine growth in the IDFdk 3&4. Extension Note #27. Research Section, Ministry of Forests, Cariboo Forest Region, Williams Lake, B.C.
Newsome, T.A., J.L. Heineman and A.F.L. Nemec. 2003. Competitive effects of trembling aspen on lodgepole pine performance in the SBS and IDF zones of the Cariboo-Chilcotin region of southcentral British Columbia. B.C. Min. For., Res. Br., Victoria, B.C. Tech. Rep. 005.
Newsome T.A., Heineman J.L., and Nemec A.F.L 2008 Competitive interactions between juvenile trembling aspen and lodgepole pine: A comparison of two interior British Columbia ecosystems For. Ecol. Manag 255 2950 -2962
Peterson, E.B. and N.M. Peterson. 1995. Aspen manager’s handbook for British Columbia. FRDA Report No. 230. B.C. Ministry of Forests, Victoria, B.C. 110 p. Available from https://www.for.gov.bc.ca/hfd/pubs/docs/Frr/Frr230.pdf
Pretzsch, H. 2009. Forest dynamics, growth and yield: From measurements to model. Chapter 9, pp. 337–380. Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg. 664 pp. Available from http://www.crc.uqam.ca/Publication/Forest%20Dynamics,%20Growth%20and%20Yield.pdf
Pretzsch H. and Biber P. 2016 Tree species mixing can increase maximum stand density Can. J. For. Res 46 1179 -1193
Radosevich S.R. and S.A. Knowe. 1992. Approaches and interpretation of experiments in forest vegetation management. Paper presented at the International Conference on Forest Vegetation Management, Auburn, U.S.A., 26 April-1 May.
Royer-Tardif S. and Bradley R.L. 2011 Evidence that soil fertility controls the mixing of jack pine with trembling aspen For. Ecol. Manage 262 1054 -1060
SAS Institute Inc. 2010. SAS OnlineDoc® 9.3., Cary, NC: SAS Institute Inc.
Simard S.W., Hagerman S.M., Sachs D.L., Heineman J.L., and Mather W.J. 2005 Conifer growth, Armillaria ostoyae root disease, and plant diversity responses to broadleaf competition reduction in mixed forests of southern interior British Columbia Can. J. For. Res 35 843 -859
Sit, V. and M. Poulin-Costello. 1994.Catalog of curves for curve fitting. Biometrics information handbook series. Handbook No. 4. March 1994. Res. Br., B.C. Min. For., Victoria, B.C. Available from http://www.for.gov.bc.ca/hfd/pubs/Docs/Bio/Bio04.htm
South D.B. and Miller J.H. 2007 Growth response analysis after early control of woody competition for 14 loblolly pine plantations in the southern U.S. For Ecol. Manage 242 569 -577
Voicu M.F. and Comeau P.G. 2006 Microclimate and spruce growth gradients adjacent to young aspen stands For. Ecol. Manage 221 13 -26
Wagner R.G. 2000 Competition and critical-period thresholds for vegetation management decisions in young conifer stands Forest. Chron 76 961 -968
Wagner R.G., Petersen T.D., Ross D.W., and Radosevich S.R. 1989 Competition thresholds for the survival and growth of ponderosa pine seedlings associated with woody and herbaceous vegetation New Forests 3 151 -170
Wagner R.G., Little K.M., Richardson B., and McNabb K. 2006 The role of vegetation management for enhancing productivity of the world’s forests Forestry 79 1 57 -79
Walmsley, M., G. Utzig, T. Vold, D. Moon and J. van Barneveld. 1980. Describing ecosystems in the field. RAB technical paper 2. Land Management Report No. 7. Province of B.C., Victoria, B.C. Available from http://www.llbc.leg.bc.ca/public/PubDocs/bcdocs/264741/Lmr007.pdf
Zeide B. 1989 Accuracy of equations describing diameter growth Can. J. For. Res 19 1283 -1286
Zeide B. 2002 Analysis of a concept: Stand density J. Sustain. Forest 14 4 51 -62
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
The Forestry Chronicle
Volume 93 • Number 03 • October 2017
Pages: 226 - 240
History
Version of record online: 2 November 2017
Copyright
© 2017.
Key Words
Mots-clés
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Other Metrics
Citations
Cite As
Harperby George. 2017. Lodgepole pine and trembling aspen competition: Neighbourhood studies within 22 to 39 year-old pine plantations of northern British Columbia. The Forestry Chronicle.
93(03): 226-240. https://doi.org/10.5558/tfc2017-031
Export Citations
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.
Cited by
1. Effects of manual brushing on 10-year survival and growth of Douglas-fir in the mixed broadleaf – shrub complex of southern interior British Columbia
